In December 2024, the CO2 Coalition published its article, “The Human Contribution to Atmospheric Carbon Dioxide”. Here is a copy of its article followed by opposing articles that show mistakes in the CO2 Coalition’s article.
The Human Contribution to Atmospheric Carbon Dioxide:
How Human Emissions are Restoring Vital Atmospheric CO2
Ferdinand Engelbeen, Renee Hannon, and David Burton
Human-Contribution-to-Atmospheric-CO2-digital-compressed.pdf
Rebuttals
About the Origin of CO2 in the Atmosphere:
Some Annotations to a Study of the CO2 Coalition
Eike Roth
SCC-Roth-Origin-of-CO2-V5-1.pdf
Pitfalls in Global Warming and Climate Change Research: Flaws in Ice Core Reconstructions of Atmospheric CO2
– The Naked King of 280 ppm at the Industrial Revolution
Dai Ato
Why the CO2 Coalition is wrong about CO2
Edwin X Berry
To be added – working on this now – Ed