“In December 2024, the CO2 Coalition published its article, “The Human Contribution to Atmospheric Carbon Dioxide,” reproduced below followed by rebuttals to this CO2 Coalition article.”
The Human Contribution to Atmospheric Carbon Dioxide: How Human Emissions are Restoring Vital Atmospheric CO2
Ferdinand Engelbeen, Renee Hannon, and David Burton – of CO2 Coalition
Human-Contribution-to-Atmospheric-CO2-digital-compressed.pdf
“Over the last 150 years, humans have emitted over 2,000 gigatons of carbon dioxide (CO2) into the atmosphere, increasing the CO2 concentration by 50 percent from pre-Industrial Revolution levels.” – How the Planet Stores Our Excess Carbon Emissions – www.caltech.edu – Even Caltech is wrong!
Rebuttals
CO2 Coalition’s physics errors
Edwin X Berry
Coming soon
About the Origin of CO2 in the Atmosphere: Some Annotations to a Study of the CO2 Coalition
Eike Roth
“The authors of [31] misinterpret some special features of the carbon cycle and sometimes they fall victim to heuristic traps. Therefore, they come to wrong conclusions, as will be shown in this reply.”
SCC-Roth-Origin-of-CO2-V5-1.pdf
Pitfalls in Global Warming and Climate Change Research: Flaws in Ice Core Reconstructions of Atmospheric CO2 – The Naked King of 280 ppm at the Industrial Revolution
Dai Ato
“This study mainly points to flaws that lead to the assumption of a mostly human-caused increase in CO2, in particular to the problems related to the methods used in the reconstruction from Antarctic ice cores and of the general consensus of 280 ppm CO2 at the onset of the Industrial Revolution.“
Atmospheric CO2: Exploring the Role of Sea Surface Temperatures and the Influence of Recent Anthropogenic CO2 Emissions
Bernard Robins
“The findings of the analyses suggest that an anthropogenic component is likely to be less than 10 % of the increase since the mid 1990s, with figures of up to around 6 % being estimated from data acquired since 1995.”
Coming soon