Berry (2019) plus 55 comments by John Nielsen-Gammon
and 55 replies by Ed Berry
Good science needs good critique and defense. This report lets you read both sides of the discussion on Berry (2019).
The Science Problem
Are the values in IPCC AR5 Fig. 6.1 valid?
The Physics Model
Is the Physics model a valid systems model?
The IPCC Model
Is the IPCC Bern model a valid systems model?
Theories Must Replicate Data
Are the 14C data a fair test?
Regent Professor, Department of Atmospheric Sciences, Texas State University
Texas State Climatologist, and Director of the Texas Center for Climate Studies.
CEO, Climate Physics LLC, Bigfork, Montana, USA.
BS, Engineering, Caltech
MS, Physics, Dartmouth College
PhD, Physics, U of Nevada
Edwin X Berry
Be the first to comment on the entire report.
Be the second to comment on the entire report.
Includes permission to read online comments and to comment.
- Nielsen-Gammon has made extensive comments on Berry (2019).
- Berry thinks Gammon’s comments are incorrect and invalid.
- What do you think?